≡ Menu

Metal vs Shingle Roof: The Pros and Cons of Each and Which Is Best for You

A new roof is one of the best investments you can make for your property. New roofing can increase your home’s value, enhance its curb appeal, and even improve its energy efficiency. For all its benefits, a new roof is one of the most expensive improvements you can invest in, too.

To ensure you get the most out of your investment, you want to ensure you choose the best roofing product for your home. It’s important to do research beforehand. If you’re already at this stage, you may be exploring the different roofing materials available.

Asphalt shingles and metal roofing are two of the most common options. The metal vs shingle roof decision can be daunting, but we’re here to help. Read on to learn the pros and cons of each, so you can make the right choice for your needs.

Metal vs Shingle Roof – Durability Pros and Cons

You want your roof to be longlasting and stand up to years of wear and tear. Metal roofing can stand regular and extreme weather conditions better than most other materials. It can withstand strong winds, snow, hail, ice, extreme heat, and extreme cold.

Metal roofing is even fire resistant. Most metal roofing is Class A fire-rated and noncombustible. If you live in an area prone to wildfires, this can provide valuable peace-of-mind.

Because it’s so durable, a metal roof also requires little maintenance. But if there is damage, repairs can be expensive. Shingle roofing can be repaired with more ease and less expense.

Metal Panels vs Shingles – Energy Saving Pros and Cons

More value is being placed on energy efficiency than ever before. Choosing an energy efficient roof can even increase your home’s value for appraisal. You may consider energy efficiency to be a top factor in your roofing decision. 

Today you have the option of cool metal roofing, an especially energy efficient metal roofing product. These emissive metal panels release absorbed heat during the warmer months and help retain heat during the colder months. Cool roofing can help you conserve energy and save money year-round.

Metal roofing is also environmentally friendly. It’s made of recycled materials, and you can recycle damaged or unused pieces. Polypropylene – often used as the underlayment -is also recyclable.

Metal Roofing Panels vs Asphalt Roofing Shingles -Installation Pros and Cons

Installing a new roof is a big undertaking and requires a lot of planning. You may be wondering about the ease of installation, as well as the expense. Shingle roofing is easier and less expensive to install than metal roofing.

But if you choose metal roofing, you can have your new metal roof retrofitted over your existing roof. This will save money from tear-off costs and even reduce waste. It may also cut down on installation time, which would also help save you money.

Installing a shingle roof requires a more intrusive process than the installation of metal roofing. Nails must go through the surface of the shingle and into your roof deck. To prevent holes and other issues, finding a reliable contractor to install a shingle roof is especially important.

Metal Roofs vs Shingle Roofs – Insurance and Warranty Pros and Cons

The insurance factor could swing either way for metal roofing. Some homeowners may get a better premium based on the longterm durability of metal roofing. Still, the expense of repairs and replacement may make insurance more expensive.

When it comes to warranty coverage for metal vs shingle roof, the answers are more clear. Shingle roofing can come with warranties from the manufacturer and the contractor. Warranties can over material defects, algae growth, manufacturer error, and contractor error.

Metal Roof vs Shingle Roof – Aesthetic Pros and Cons

While you want your roof to be durable and dependable, you want it to look good, too. Both metal and shingle roofing products offer various appearance options. Which material is best for you depends on your unique needs.

Metal roofing, for example, is available in any color, so you may be able to find the ideal tone for your taste. Metal roofing is also available in different shapes and sizes. You can even find metal roofing that mimics the look of shingles or tiles.

But metal also has a high-glare issue and is considered to look more industrial, so some Home Owners Associations don’t allow metal roofing. Shingle roofing is still more common than metal, and the look is more traditional. You’ll need to consider a range of factors to figure out which option is ideal for your aesthetic needs.

Metal Roofing vs Asphalt Roofing – Miscellaneous Pros and Cons

Metal and shingle roofs each offer unique advantages and drawbacks. For example, metal roofing installed on a coastal property may not come with a warranty. This is because shingles are heavier and are easier to replace in the event of damage during a hurricane or other high wind occurrence.

Shingle roofs though, often have issues with moisture. If excess moisture is unable to dry, shingles can become prone to mold, mildew, and even algae. Shingles may also shed the granules of the color coating, which can get stuck in gutters or pipes.

Metal is more lightweight, so it won’t weigh down on your home or business structure. But because shingles are heavier, they can withstand more weight and foot traffic. With so many factors at play, you’ll want to learn more about metal roofing and shingle roofing before making a final decision.

Beyond New Roofing – Explore More for All Your Home Improvement Needs

Installing a new roof is a major project, but there are countless other home improvement projects. If you’re thinking about buying or selling a home, those decisions need extra attention, too. So if you have questions that go beyond the metal vs shingle roof debate, you’re in the right place.

We have a wealth of articles about construction, home renovation, buying a new home, and more. We have articles about corrugated roofing, finding a local handyman, and even guidance on finding a home loan. Browse our blog to explore more information and tips.